I thought it might be interesting to take a look at Mascoma Lake and Crystal Lake waterfront property sales over the past 5 years to see what if any effect the recession has had on lakefront values. As NNEREN does not offer any reports specifically designed for waterfront property, it is more difficult to come up with specific comparative information. I ended up printing all the listings and trying to compare sales over the years by using assessed values, which were updated by the Town of Enfield in 2010.
Generally speaking, waterfront sales on both lakes have been solid both this year and last year with 11 properties selling on the lakes in 2010 and 7 closed and 1 pending at this point in 2011. That compares with 3 sales for both lakes in 2009, 5 in 2008, 11 in 2007 and 3 in 2006. It is interesting to note that lakefront sales in terms of unit numbers and sales dollars have been relatively strong this year and in 2010 in spite of or perhaps because of the recession.
One thing that stands out year to year is that in 2010, 9 of the 11 sales were on Mascoma Lake and sold on average at approximately 1.13% of assessed value. In 2011, 5 out of 7 sales were on Crystal Lake and have been on average selling for approximately .98% of assessed value. It seems 2011 has been a good year to buy Lakefront property, particularly on Crystal Lake

If you are looking for a camp on Crystal Lake, 80 Hawley Drive (MLS 4058271) appears to be well priced at $329,000 when compared to its assessed value of $378,000. The price also compares favorably with recent sales of similar 4 season camps with approximately 100 feet of shore frontage.

If you would consider renovating an antique cape on a nice .74 -acre lot with 401 feet of water frontage, 436 Lockhaven Rd. (MLS 4085081) is priced at its assessed value of $349,900. While not having the water views, this would make a great home with its very nice lake frontage to enjoy.

Lastly, if you are looking for a place to park a camper and a boat on Mascoma Lake, how about a .15 acre lot with 59 feet of lake frontage a public and a sewer hook up available on Rt. 4A (MLS4079586) priced at $134,900, $8,100 below its assessed value. While you won’t have much elbowroom you will have very inexpensive access to a great lake.
A particular sale that stands out in 2010 is 64 Shaker Boulevard on Mascoma Lake, a very nice four season cottage with 230 feet of shore frontage on .6 acres that sold for $350,000 after just 19 days on the market in October of 2010. This same cottage was listed for sale in late May of 2007 at $274,900 and sold after 9 days on the market in a bidding war for $350,000. As good an indicator as you will find that lakefront values have remained reasonably stable over the last few years.
When you look at the lakefront inventory remaining on the market at this time, it shakes out like this. There are 7 properties currently listed on Crystal Lake and 6 on Mascoma Lake, of the 13 properties, 9 are priced well above their assessed value and in general have spent significant time on the market. The remaining 4 properties are priced at or below assessed value which indicates to me that the Sellers are in tune with the actual market and motivated to sell.
If you are considering buying property on either Mascoma Lake or Crystal Lake, please come in and talk with Carol or I. Not only can we help you sort through the market data; we can help you assess all the attributes that contribute to the value of a particular lakefront property. Having just purchased property ourselves on Mascoma Lake in 2010, we are uniquely qualified to help with your lakefront purchase.
Cheers, Matt